Clean Oakland
  • Home
  • Sanjiv Handa
  • Gene's Blog
  • Rotunda RFP
    • Lawsuit against Rotunda Partners II >
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Building
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Garage
      • Charges in massive investment fraud case
      • Phil Tagami's Obligation
  • Gene Hazzard -Keeping eyes open
    • Hazzard substitution of attorney
    • Public Record Request [PORT] about the $100,000.00 deposit, NO Straight answer.
    • Court Reporter Transcript
    • The Power Broker? >
      • Robert Moses >
        • NY Times February 14, 2007
  • Chronology of Tagami's scheme of Private-Public Partnership with City Projects
  • Another Tagami scheme - Rotunda Building deal
    • Eight Years Later, Tagami Still Hasn’t Started Rotunda Project City Fails to Hold Developer Responsible
    • 1630 San Pablo - Parcel 2
    • Rotunda Building Loan
    • Post -Tagami Failed to Make Payments on Rotunda Development Loan
    • City Urges No Action in Tagami’s Failure to Make Payments on $12 Million Loan
  • Oakland Army Base
    • Port to Give Tagami $600 Million Exclusive
    • OAB - Wikipedia
    • OAB - Military Museum
    • Army Base Gateway Redevelopment Project
    • BAAQMD Comments on Air Monitoring Work Plan
    • Cost Sharing Agreement
    • OAB Rezoning and LDDA update
  • Billboards in Oakland
  • Port of Oakland
  • Oakland Raiders?
  • Who is running Oakland?
    • Jerry Brown
    • Don Perata
    • Judge Robert B. Freedman
    • Jacques Barzaghi
    • Gawfco Enterprises
    • Deception
    • Doug Bloch
    • Phil Tagami >
      • SF Business Times November 20, 2005
      • Rotunda wrestling
      • A conversation with Oakland developer Phil Tagami
      • Audit of $91 million Fox Theater project
      • Tagami Conflict
      • CCIG Response to Oakland Works
      • Oakland developer Phil Tagami named to state medical board
      • ‘Shotgun Phil’ hits another bullseye — with governor’s help
  • CleanOakland Store
  • CenterPoint Properties

Federal Judge Rules Against Oakland, Allows Coal Terminal Lawsuit to Proceed

4/20/2017

0 Comments

 
THURSDAY, APRIL 20, 2017
​By Darwin BondGraham
PictureCoal opponents gathered outside of the federal courthouse in San Francisco this morning.

A federal judge ruled today that a lawsuit brought by the developer of a proposed coal export terminal can proceed against the City of Oakland. The court rejected
the city’s motion to have the lawsuit dismissed.

The dispute involves a proposed marine terminal to be built in West Oakland. In 2015, it was revealed that the project's developer, the Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal, or OBOT, was planning to ship millions of tons of coal annually through the facility.

In response, the Oakland City Council passed an ordinance banning the storage and handling of coal on the grounds that it would endanger the health and safety of Oakland residents and workers.

Today's court ruling means the lawsuit will go to trial early next year, unless the city and developer settle. The city and OBOT have been in mediation since April 17. A settlement could cost Oakland taxpayers millions.

OBOT filed its lawsuit against Oakland on December 7 of last year, contending the coal ban doesn’t apply to its project, because the company already "vested" rights to build the coal export hub in 2013. Back then, Oakland didn't have a law banning coal storage and handling. OBOT contends that it's the city's rules and regulations in effect in 2013 that apply to it, not the subsequent coal ban.

"It may be Oakland has an uphill battle in this case," said U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria at today's hearing.

During today's hearing, Chhabria extensively questioned Oakland's attorney, Kevin Siegel, about why the city thinks the lawsuit should be dismissed. Siegel argued that OBOT never actually vested rights to specifically handle coal at the terminal. According to Siegel, any ability for OBOT to handle coal needed to be "expressly" stated in the 2013 development agreement, but it wasn't.

"It allows us to impose new regulations where there’s silence in the development agreement," said Siegel.

But Chhabria peppered Siegel with skeptical questions about contract law.

"I disagree with you in terms of vested rights," the judge told Siegel. "The development agreement gives OBOT vested rights to develop a terminal and use that under Oakland’s regulations that existed at the time the development agreement was signed."

Chhabria didn't rule entirely in favor of OBOT today, however. The judge said he is willing to allow two environmental organizations, the Sierra Club and San Francisco Baykeeper, to intervene in the lawsuit.

OBOT's attorneys have sought to exclude the groups from participating in the case.

Attorneys for the Sierra Club and San Francisco Baykeeper argued that the City of Oakland won't necessarily defend the full set of environmental interests that their members are concerned about, therefore the judge should let them into the case.

"The city has to balance environmental interests with the financial pressure from OBOT," said Colin O’Brien, an attorney with Earthjustice, who is representing the groups.

He asked whether the City of Oakland would vigorously defend environmental goals if faced with a potentially expensive or damaging outcome that could be avoided through a settlement. "The answer is 'no,'" O'Brien told the judge.

"They should not be in this case," countered Meredith Shaw, an attorney for OBOT. "The only impact is additional delay, and OBOT would be forced to fight this battle on three fronts instead of one."

Chhabria dismissed Shaw's argument with a joke: "So the concern is OBOT and the little law firm it hired will get crushed by the city and Sierra Club and SF Baykeeper?" The courtroom audience laughed; OBOT is represented by attorneys from Quinn Emanuel, one of the largest business law firms in the world.

Chhabria said he'd need more time to think about the proposed intervention by the two environmental groups, but he appeared to be leaning strongly in favor of allowing them to participate.

The judge also rejected a proposal from Oakland to schedule a trial in September 2018. OBOT's attorneys argued that delays will harm OBOT financially. Trial is set for January 16 of next year.

Attorneys on all sides declined to comment for this report.

Phil Tagami, the owner and manager of OBOT, who was present for today's hearing, told the Express "no comment" as he exited the courtroom.

http://www.eastbayexpress.com/SevenDays/archives/2017/04/20/federal-judge-rules-against-oakland-allows-coal-terminal-lawsuit-to-proceed​

Picture
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Gene Hazzard

    Don't Be Envious of Evil Men
    1Do not be envious of evil men, Nor desire to be with them; 2For their minds devise violence, And their lips talk of trouble.…

    Archives

    February 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014

    Categories

    All
    AMB
    Army Base
    City Of Oakland
    Coal
    Dan Siegel
    Garage
    Gene Hazzard
    Grant
    Hamid Moghadam
    Kaplan
    Oakland
    Phil Tagami
    Prologis
    Public Ethics Commission
    Rebecca Kaplan
    Redevelopment Agency
    Rotunda
    Tiger
    Wharf
    WOSP
    Zhao Liang

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • Sanjiv Handa
  • Gene's Blog
  • Rotunda RFP
    • Lawsuit against Rotunda Partners II >
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Building
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Garage
      • Charges in massive investment fraud case
      • Phil Tagami's Obligation
  • Gene Hazzard -Keeping eyes open
    • Hazzard substitution of attorney
    • Public Record Request [PORT] about the $100,000.00 deposit, NO Straight answer.
    • Court Reporter Transcript
    • The Power Broker? >
      • Robert Moses >
        • NY Times February 14, 2007
  • Chronology of Tagami's scheme of Private-Public Partnership with City Projects
  • Another Tagami scheme - Rotunda Building deal
    • Eight Years Later, Tagami Still Hasn’t Started Rotunda Project City Fails to Hold Developer Responsible
    • 1630 San Pablo - Parcel 2
    • Rotunda Building Loan
    • Post -Tagami Failed to Make Payments on Rotunda Development Loan
    • City Urges No Action in Tagami’s Failure to Make Payments on $12 Million Loan
  • Oakland Army Base
    • Port to Give Tagami $600 Million Exclusive
    • OAB - Wikipedia
    • OAB - Military Museum
    • Army Base Gateway Redevelopment Project
    • BAAQMD Comments on Air Monitoring Work Plan
    • Cost Sharing Agreement
    • OAB Rezoning and LDDA update
  • Billboards in Oakland
  • Port of Oakland
  • Oakland Raiders?
  • Who is running Oakland?
    • Jerry Brown
    • Don Perata
    • Judge Robert B. Freedman
    • Jacques Barzaghi
    • Gawfco Enterprises
    • Deception
    • Doug Bloch
    • Phil Tagami >
      • SF Business Times November 20, 2005
      • Rotunda wrestling
      • A conversation with Oakland developer Phil Tagami
      • Audit of $91 million Fox Theater project
      • Tagami Conflict
      • CCIG Response to Oakland Works
      • Oakland developer Phil Tagami named to state medical board
      • ‘Shotgun Phil’ hits another bullseye — with governor’s help
  • CleanOakland Store
  • CenterPoint Properties