Clean Oakland
  • Home
  • Sanjiv Handa
  • Gene's Blog
  • Rotunda RFP
    • Lawsuit against Rotunda Partners II >
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Building
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Garage
      • Charges in massive investment fraud case
      • Phil Tagami's Obligation
  • Gene Hazzard -Keeping eyes open
    • Hazzard substitution of attorney
    • Public Record Request [PORT] about the $100,000.00 deposit, NO Straight answer.
    • Court Reporter Transcript
    • The Power Broker? >
      • Robert Moses >
        • NY Times February 14, 2007
  • Chronology of Tagami's scheme of Private-Public Partnership with City Projects
  • Another Tagami scheme - Rotunda Building deal
    • Eight Years Later, Tagami Still Hasn’t Started Rotunda Project City Fails to Hold Developer Responsible
    • 1630 San Pablo - Parcel 2
    • Rotunda Building Loan
    • Post -Tagami Failed to Make Payments on Rotunda Development Loan
    • City Urges No Action in Tagami’s Failure to Make Payments on $12 Million Loan
  • Oakland Army Base
    • Port to Give Tagami $600 Million Exclusive
    • OAB - Wikipedia
    • OAB - Military Museum
    • Army Base Gateway Redevelopment Project
    • BAAQMD Comments on Air Monitoring Work Plan
    • Cost Sharing Agreement
    • OAB Rezoning and LDDA update
  • Billboards in Oakland
  • Port of Oakland
  • Oakland Raiders?
  • Who is running Oakland?
    • Jerry Brown
    • Don Perata
    • Judge Robert B. Freedman
    • Jacques Barzaghi
    • Gawfco Enterprises
    • Deception
    • Doug Bloch
    • Phil Tagami >
      • SF Business Times November 20, 2005
      • Rotunda wrestling
      • A conversation with Oakland developer Phil Tagami
      • Audit of $91 million Fox Theater project
      • Tagami Conflict
      • CCIG Response to Oakland Works
      • Oakland developer Phil Tagami named to state medical board
      • ‘Shotgun Phil’ hits another bullseye — with governor’s help
  • CleanOakland Store
  • CenterPoint Properties

Oakland City Council packed for special hearing on Utah coal shipping plan

9/22/2015

0 Comments

 
By Mike Blasky The Contra Costa Times
First Published Sep 22 2015 12:21PM
Picture
(Francisco Kjolseth | Tribune file photo) Coal trucked from central Utah piles up at the Levan transfer station south of Nephi where it is loaded on Union Pacific freight cars bound for California.

Controversy » At a special City Council hearing, the heated debate boils down to jobs vs. health.

Oakland, Calif. • Kwame Nitoto doesn't want to hear about "safer" coal or the economic benefits of shipping fossil fuels from Utah through Oakland.

There will always be new commodities to ship, more jobs to create. But coal isn't the future, and Oakland's residents can't afford to live in the past, he said — not when their health is at stake.

"Let's stop pretending this is coal versus jobs. It's not about that," said Nitoto, program director for Positive Communication Practices, a Bay Area agency that works with at-risk youths. "If we're going to say health and safety is a priority, don't do it. Just don't do it."

Nitoto was one of the hundreds of speakers who drew applause or jeers at a crowded, passionate special council meeting Monday to discuss a developer's contentious plan to ship millions of tons of Utah coal through the city's $250 million bulk shipping and logistics terminal development at the former Army Base, a cornerstone project for the city.

Utah's Community Impact Board, which oversees federal mining royalties given to the state to help mitigate impacts on local communities, has committed $53 million to the project. It is a controversial shift from the board's traditional focus on such things as local government buildings, water projects and roads. But supporters defend the low-interest loan as an investment in reviving the struggling economies of the four rural Utah counties that propose to take an ownership interest in the port project.

The hearing Monday was a first step for city officials, many of whom have already publicly slammed the plan, to gather testimony about the health and environmental impacts of shipping coal and other fossil fuels through West Oakland before taking steps to formally reject it. That wasn't an option for the council on Monday, as the hearing was only a fact-finding mission.

Most of the speakers focused on the health and environment concerns.

Dr. Muntu Davis, Alameda County's public health director, said children and seniors are particularly vulnerable to coal dust from rail transport, especially those in the city's poor neighborhoods.

Children in West Oakland are already twice as likely to suffer from asthma and respiratory disease, he said.

"Coal dust always comes out, and that dust will sit there. It's not like it will just blow away," he said. "And if it does get washed away, it will wash into the bay."

The coal proposal by developer Phil Tagami, who is also the city-designated agent for the project, has drawn the ire of many elected officials since it was uncovered this year by the Richfield Reaper reporting on the state's interest in shipping coal at the new bulk terminal adjacent to the Port of Oakland.

Terminal Logistics Solutions, or TLS, will start building the Bulk and Oversized Terminal at the Oakland Global Trade & Logistics Center later this year and hopes to finish the 35-acre project in 2017.

Tagami didn't attend the hearing, but many of his supporters did. A lawyer working for Tagami's company told the council the city might not have jurisdiction to ban coal from the terminal because the project was already approved and the federal government has jurisdiction of rail transport.

Jerry Bridges, president of TLS and a former executive director of the Port Authority, told the council that his company is reviewing the viability of all commodities, including coal. But if the terminal chooses to export coal, Oakland has an opportunity to show the world it's possible to transport it safely.

"Our commitment to the safety and health of our workers is a top priority, and we will operate in a manner that meets and exceeds all industry standards," Bridges said.

The council chambers were filled to capacity as soon as doors opened Monday, sending extra speakers to the city's overflow meeting rooms downstairs.

Dozens of residents wore red "Beyond coal exports" shirts and carried "no coal" exports sign.

Others came to the meeting concerned about the prospect of losing jobs if the city passes on coal, a lucrative but increasingly scarce resource as more people stop using fossil fuels for energy.

Several dozen construction workers wearing yellow "I Support Oakland Jobs" T-shirts packed City Hall a few hours before the hearing to support the coal plan, although not every worker seemed interested in the night's content. Many of the workers said they weren't sure which side of the argument they were on, and most only ceded their speaking time to pro-coal lawyers and executives without making a statement.

Debbie Niemeier, a civil and environmental engineering professor at UC Davis, and an expert in emissions, said 10.5 million tons of coal means 30 million tons of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.

And coal-burning in Asia impacts U.S. residents on the West Coast, she said, with greenhouse gases a real concern for the world.


"Climate change is responsible for the sea level rise and exacerbating the California drought," Niemeier said.

Others took a blunt view of the situation.

Kevin Barnes, a pastor at Abyssinian Missionary Baptist Church, told the council that many of Oakland residents were poor and starving and need real jobs that pay living wages.

There is a drug crisis impacting the city's youth, he said.

"With all this cocaine in the streets," Barnes said, "you're worried about coal?"

But others cautioned that the short-term economic benefits of coal aren't necessarily good for the long-term residents.

Derrick Muhammad, a member of the International Longshore & Warehouse Union Local 10, which recently voted to oppose the handling of coal, said prostitution is a form of employment. But not all money is good money.

Any benefit from coal, Muhammad said, "is far outweighed by its detriment."

Mike Blasky covers Oakland City Hall. Contact him at 510-208-6429. Follow him at Twitter.com/blasky.

— The Salt Lake Tribune contributed to this story.

http://www.sltrib.com/home/2979432-155/oakland-city-council-packed-for-special

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Gene Hazzard

    Don't Be Envious of Evil Men
    1Do not be envious of evil men, Nor desire to be with them; 2For their minds devise violence, And their lips talk of trouble.…

    Archives

    February 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014

    Categories

    All
    AMB
    Army Base
    City Of Oakland
    Coal
    Dan Siegel
    Garage
    Gene Hazzard
    Grant
    Hamid Moghadam
    Kaplan
    Oakland
    Phil Tagami
    Prologis
    Public Ethics Commission
    Rebecca Kaplan
    Redevelopment Agency
    Rotunda
    Tiger
    Wharf
    WOSP
    Zhao Liang

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • Sanjiv Handa
  • Gene's Blog
  • Rotunda RFP
    • Lawsuit against Rotunda Partners II >
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Building
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Garage
      • Charges in massive investment fraud case
      • Phil Tagami's Obligation
  • Gene Hazzard -Keeping eyes open
    • Hazzard substitution of attorney
    • Public Record Request [PORT] about the $100,000.00 deposit, NO Straight answer.
    • Court Reporter Transcript
    • The Power Broker? >
      • Robert Moses >
        • NY Times February 14, 2007
  • Chronology of Tagami's scheme of Private-Public Partnership with City Projects
  • Another Tagami scheme - Rotunda Building deal
    • Eight Years Later, Tagami Still Hasn’t Started Rotunda Project City Fails to Hold Developer Responsible
    • 1630 San Pablo - Parcel 2
    • Rotunda Building Loan
    • Post -Tagami Failed to Make Payments on Rotunda Development Loan
    • City Urges No Action in Tagami’s Failure to Make Payments on $12 Million Loan
  • Oakland Army Base
    • Port to Give Tagami $600 Million Exclusive
    • OAB - Wikipedia
    • OAB - Military Museum
    • Army Base Gateway Redevelopment Project
    • BAAQMD Comments on Air Monitoring Work Plan
    • Cost Sharing Agreement
    • OAB Rezoning and LDDA update
  • Billboards in Oakland
  • Port of Oakland
  • Oakland Raiders?
  • Who is running Oakland?
    • Jerry Brown
    • Don Perata
    • Judge Robert B. Freedman
    • Jacques Barzaghi
    • Gawfco Enterprises
    • Deception
    • Doug Bloch
    • Phil Tagami >
      • SF Business Times November 20, 2005
      • Rotunda wrestling
      • A conversation with Oakland developer Phil Tagami
      • Audit of $91 million Fox Theater project
      • Tagami Conflict
      • CCIG Response to Oakland Works
      • Oakland developer Phil Tagami named to state medical board
      • ‘Shotgun Phil’ hits another bullseye — with governor’s help
  • CleanOakland Store
  • CenterPoint Properties