Clean Oakland
  • Home
  • Sanjiv Handa
  • Gene's Blog
  • Rotunda RFP
    • Lawsuit against Rotunda Partners II >
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Building
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Garage
      • Charges in massive investment fraud case
      • Phil Tagami's Obligation
  • Gene Hazzard -Keeping eyes open
    • Hazzard substitution of attorney
    • Public Record Request [PORT] about the $100,000.00 deposit, NO Straight answer.
    • Court Reporter Transcript
    • The Power Broker? >
      • Robert Moses >
        • NY Times February 14, 2007
  • Chronology of Tagami's scheme of Private-Public Partnership with City Projects
  • Another Tagami scheme - Rotunda Building deal
    • Eight Years Later, Tagami Still Hasn’t Started Rotunda Project City Fails to Hold Developer Responsible
    • 1630 San Pablo - Parcel 2
    • Rotunda Building Loan
    • Post -Tagami Failed to Make Payments on Rotunda Development Loan
    • City Urges No Action in Tagami’s Failure to Make Payments on $12 Million Loan
  • Oakland Army Base
    • Port to Give Tagami $600 Million Exclusive
    • OAB - Wikipedia
    • OAB - Military Museum
    • Army Base Gateway Redevelopment Project
    • BAAQMD Comments on Air Monitoring Work Plan
    • Cost Sharing Agreement
    • OAB Rezoning and LDDA update
  • Billboards in Oakland
  • Port of Oakland
  • Oakland Raiders?
  • Who is running Oakland?
    • Jerry Brown
    • Don Perata
    • Judge Robert B. Freedman
    • Jacques Barzaghi
    • Gawfco Enterprises
    • Deception
    • Doug Bloch
    • Phil Tagami >
      • SF Business Times November 20, 2005
      • Rotunda wrestling
      • A conversation with Oakland developer Phil Tagami
      • Audit of $91 million Fox Theater project
      • Tagami Conflict
      • CCIG Response to Oakland Works
      • Oakland developer Phil Tagami named to state medical board
      • ‘Shotgun Phil’ hits another bullseye — with governor’s help
  • CleanOakland Store
  • CenterPoint Properties

Op-ed: Oakland coal port is private investors exploiting state fund

11/6/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture

​By David Irvine
First Published Nov 06 2015 05:30PM 

In Piute County this year, the town of Circleville received $835,250 from Utah's Permanent Community Impact Fund to build a medical center to serve its roughly 500 residents.

For Kanab in Kane County, the fund provided a $680,000 grant and a similar loan to mitigate the risk of floods in Tom's Canyon.

Castle Dale in Emery County received $3,585,000 in grants and loans from the fund to build a new city hall.
​

All across Utah, projects supported by the state's Community Impact Fund have enhanced the safety, security and quality of life in communities affected by mineral extraction.
The fund, which was created by state and federal law to distribute royalties from fossil fuels mined from federal lands, has the express mission of providing grants and loans — generally limited to a maximum of $5 million — to "subdivisions of the state" for construction or maintenance of "public facilities."
So the decision by the Community Impact Board last spring to approve a $53 million loan to Carbon, Emery, Sevier and Sanpete counties to invest in a deep-water export terminal in the Port of Oakland, Calif., is disturbing.

Even more troubling is the process the board used to fast-track the decision. The board approved the loan April 2 under a "request for special consideration" without holding a single public hearing. A presentation to the board on the Oakland terminal project was made March 7 in a closed-door meeting, but no effort was made to engage the public in what was a dramatic departure from the guidelines and intent of the Community Impact Fund program.

The formal application for the loan from Carbon County wasn't even submitted until April 28, nearly four weeks after the board approved the loan, and it included almost none of the usual financial information required.

Further, Jeff Holt, an investment banker with BMO Capital Markets who is also chair of the Utah Transportation Commission and until late 2014 was a member of the Community Impact Board, was a key player in developing the deal. BMO Capital Markets is actively involved in financing construction of rail lines across Utah to deliver goods — primarily coal — to a West Coast port, and that bank is likely to reap profits, perhaps in the millions, from the railroad project.

The appearance of a conflict of interest is obvious, and heightened by the hurried, unorthodox decision-making process employed by the board.

And given the volatility in the energy market and the rapid rise in alternative energy around the world, a project to subsidize coal exports demands a thorough investigation. The board should have carefully assessed the financial risks associated with a $53 million loan to be repaid over 30 years using anticipated, and perhaps imaginary, revenues from coal shipments.

Instead, public engagement was stifled and questions remain.

Even members of the Community Impact Board worried aloud about what they were doing. According to the minutes of the April 2 meeting, "The board expressed concern about the legalities of the project."

Then members voted to approve the loan.

The Community Impact Board contradicted the letter and spirit of a law meant to benefit Utahns with community-based projects when it fast-tracked the process to approve an oversized loan for a risky venture in California.
The people of Utah deserve better.

The $53 million loan appears to have been contingent on getting a green light from Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes. Reyes should announce loud and clear that using taxpayers' money to fund this kind of project violates the law, but even without such an announcement, the Community Impact Board should reverse its decision to approve the loan.

The Community Impact Fund needs to be protected from exploitation by private investors gambling on ill-advised, shortsighted projects.

http://www.sltrib.com/opinion/3142361-155/op-ed-oakland-coal-port-is-private


0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Gene Hazzard

    Don't Be Envious of Evil Men
    1Do not be envious of evil men, Nor desire to be with them; 2For their minds devise violence, And their lips talk of trouble.…

    Archives

    February 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014

    Categories

    All
    AMB
    Army Base
    City Of Oakland
    Coal
    Dan Siegel
    Garage
    Gene Hazzard
    Grant
    Hamid Moghadam
    Kaplan
    Oakland
    Phil Tagami
    Prologis
    Public Ethics Commission
    Rebecca Kaplan
    Redevelopment Agency
    Rotunda
    Tiger
    Wharf
    WOSP
    Zhao Liang

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • Sanjiv Handa
  • Gene's Blog
  • Rotunda RFP
    • Lawsuit against Rotunda Partners II >
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Building
      • Facts you should know about the Rotunda Garage
      • Charges in massive investment fraud case
      • Phil Tagami's Obligation
  • Gene Hazzard -Keeping eyes open
    • Hazzard substitution of attorney
    • Public Record Request [PORT] about the $100,000.00 deposit, NO Straight answer.
    • Court Reporter Transcript
    • The Power Broker? >
      • Robert Moses >
        • NY Times February 14, 2007
  • Chronology of Tagami's scheme of Private-Public Partnership with City Projects
  • Another Tagami scheme - Rotunda Building deal
    • Eight Years Later, Tagami Still Hasn’t Started Rotunda Project City Fails to Hold Developer Responsible
    • 1630 San Pablo - Parcel 2
    • Rotunda Building Loan
    • Post -Tagami Failed to Make Payments on Rotunda Development Loan
    • City Urges No Action in Tagami’s Failure to Make Payments on $12 Million Loan
  • Oakland Army Base
    • Port to Give Tagami $600 Million Exclusive
    • OAB - Wikipedia
    • OAB - Military Museum
    • Army Base Gateway Redevelopment Project
    • BAAQMD Comments on Air Monitoring Work Plan
    • Cost Sharing Agreement
    • OAB Rezoning and LDDA update
  • Billboards in Oakland
  • Port of Oakland
  • Oakland Raiders?
  • Who is running Oakland?
    • Jerry Brown
    • Don Perata
    • Judge Robert B. Freedman
    • Jacques Barzaghi
    • Gawfco Enterprises
    • Deception
    • Doug Bloch
    • Phil Tagami >
      • SF Business Times November 20, 2005
      • Rotunda wrestling
      • A conversation with Oakland developer Phil Tagami
      • Audit of $91 million Fox Theater project
      • Tagami Conflict
      • CCIG Response to Oakland Works
      • Oakland developer Phil Tagami named to state medical board
      • ‘Shotgun Phil’ hits another bullseye — with governor’s help
  • CleanOakland Store
  • CenterPoint Properties